By using technological services with regards to arbitration procedures, one may claim that reaching a fair result in alignment with expectation of the parties would be ensured without any substantial delay or compromise.
As of today, novel coronavirus has been continuing to overwhelmingly impact on every aspect of daily lives of global society, including judicial procedures. It is seen that courts within numerous jurisdictions have halted their operations and hearing, as well as other procedural transactions have been postponed which will undeniably cause an immense delay and workload said court’s judgments and work processes.
Having said that, thanks to its already known advantages over litigation, arbitration may cope with adverse effects of the pandemic, at least the ones within legal proceedings.
Considering increasingly advanced features offered by information and communication technologies, implementing online facilities in arbitration proceedings is a critical step for meeting the expectations of Parties.
By using technological services with regards to arbitration procedures, one may claim that reaching a fair result in alignment with expectation of the parties would be ensured without any substantial delay or compromise.
In this context, Istanbul Arbitration Centre (‘’ISTAC’’) has published Online Hearing Rules and Procedures (‘’Rules and Procedures’’) in order to ease the potential concerns concerning arbitration procedures.
Although, some other arbitration institutions have already announced their online rules and procedures regarding the testimonies of the witnesses, ISTAC is the first one to publish its Rules and Procedures regarding the online hearings.
According to the Rules and Procedures online hearings can be conducted on both video conferencing and teleconferencing utilities.
The Rules and Procedures also state that decision to conduct hearing online can be given by sole arbitrator or arbitral tribunal upon request of a party or ex officio.
Notably, importance of the right to be heard is clearly emphasized in the Rules and Procedures. As per to Article 7 of the latter sole arbitrator or arbitral tribunal should take due care to ensure that each party has the possibility to attend the hearing and that right to fair hearing is not violated. Furthermore, it is also stated that if sole arbitrator or arbitral tribunal is convinced that right to fair hearing is violated during the hearing, the hearing can be terminated at any time provided that the justification is stated.
In addition, it is stated that different procedures or rules can be established by the sole arbitrator or arbitral tribunal according to the Rules and Procedures.
Following these, Rules and Procedures include provisions regarding preparations for the hearing, people to attend to the hearing, document submission during the hearing, management of the hearing, having witness or expert during the hearing, using interpreter in the hearing, recording of the hearing.
For reference, ISTAC Online Hearing Rules and Procedures is provided below.
Should you have any question or inquiries about Turkish and international arbitration practice and disputes, please do not hesitate to contact us at info@guzeloglu.legal.
ISTAC ONLINE HEARING RULES AND PROCEDURES
ARTICLE 1 – AIM AND SCOPE OF APPLICATION The hereby established Online Hearing Rules and Procedures aim to determine the rules and principles applicable to the hearings which the participants will conduct without physical attendance, through teleconference or video conference, during arbitration proceedings subject to ISTAC Rules. For the purpose of these Rules and Procedures, the term “hearing” shall mean online hearing.
At the request of any party, or upon its own initiative, the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal, may designate rules and procedures other than those provided herein.
ARTICLE 2 – DECISION TO HOLD HEARINGS
At the request of any party or in cases where the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal deems appropriate, hearings or meetings may be conducted through video conference or teleconference.
ARTICLE 3 – HEARING PREPARATIONS The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal, after having consulted the parties, shall determine: the software to be used for the purpose of the hearing; the necessary measures to be taken to ensure the confidentiality and the safety of the hearing, phone numbers, links, user names or passwords or any other matters necessary for participation in the hearing; the technical infrastructure of the hearing, and shall inform the parties of such.
Hearing participants shall be responsible for providing the technical equipment and software required for their participation, and shall ensure that the place in which they are located is adequate and safe for the hearing to take place.
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal or the parties, may request technical support from the ISTAC Secretariat regarding the hearing. The ISTAC Secretariat will provide explanations regarding technical issues and technical support to the parties and the arbitrators, within its means.
ARTICLE 4 – PEOPLE TO ATTEND THE HEARING
Before the hearing, the parties shall notify the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal of the hearing participants.
During the hearing, no third party other than those notified to and permitted by the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal may attend the hearing.
ARTICLE 5 – CONDUCT OF THE HEARING During the hearing, only one person shall speak at any one time and all other participants shall have their microphones muted so that image and sound quality are not affected. The party seeking to speak, shall do so by permission of the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal.
ARTICLE 6 – PRESENTING DOCUMENTS AT THE HEARING
During the hearing, with the permission of the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal, documents may be transmitted electronically.
ARTICLE 7 – RIGHT TO BE HEARD AT THE HEARING
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal shall make every effort necessary to ensure that the parties and any others concerned have the opportunity to attend the hearings and that their right to be heard is not violated.
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal, in cases where it is convinced during the hearing that right to be heard has been violated, may end the hearing at any time and give its reasons for doing so.
ARTICLE 8 – HAVING WITNESSES OR EXPERTS HEARD DURING THE HEARINGIn cases where it is decided that a witness or an expert will be heard during an online hearing, the witness or the expert shall attend the hearing through video conference or video call. The witness or the expert attending an online hearing shall be present in front of the camera with their face clearly visible.
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal shall decide whether any documents can be made available for the witness or the expert. The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal may allow a particular document to be made available to the witness during the hearing. In cases where the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal deems it appropriate, the documents to be presented to the witness can be transmitted electronically during the hearing and questions can be asked regarding those documents.
ARTICLE 9 – USE OF INTERPRETER The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal, in cases where it is deemed necessary, may allow the use of an interpreter. In such cases, the party requiring translation will provide an interpreter to attend the hearing. The credentials of the interpreter will be provided to the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal in advance. The interpreters may attend the hearing together with the person for whom they shall interpret or they may attend the hearing from a third location.
ARTICLE 10 – RECORD OF THE HEARING
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal may, by informing the parties, decide that the hearing shall be recorded by audio or video. Such recordings shall be shared with the parties following the end of the hearing.
The Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal may, at the expense of the parties, decide to have the recordings transcribed.
It is forbidden to record any audio or visuals during any stage of the hearing, without leave of the Sole Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal.